How to write a return policy that helps you sell
A clear return policy reassures hesitant buyers. What to include, how to word it, and where to put it so shoppers see it before they pay.
T The CROMagnet team, Store audit research 2 min read Updated
Buying from a store you do not know carries a small risk, and a return policy is how you tell the shopper that you have thought about it. Many people open the policy before they pay. If they cannot find one, or if it reads like a legal threat, they are more likely to close the tab.
This is not legal advice. Check what your country requires, since consumer law varies. What follows is about the writing.
Answer five questions in the first screen
- How long do I have? Give a number of days and say when the clock starts: delivery date or order date.
- What can I send back? State the condition, such as unworn with tags or unopened.
- What can I not send back? List the exceptions plainly: final sale, personalised items, hygiene products.
- Who pays for postage? Say it. If the customer pays, say how much or how it is deducted.
- How fast do I get my money back? Name the number of days after you receive the parcel, and the method.
Use plain sentences
Compare two versions of the same rule.
The Company reserves the right to refuse returns of items not meeting the criteria set forth in Section 4.2.
You can return unworn items within 30 days of delivery. We refund to your original payment method within 5 working days of receiving them.
The second is the one a shopper will believe.
Put a short version where decisions happen
A full policy page is necessary, but few people go looking for it mid-purchase. Add a one-line summary on the product page and in the cart: "30-day returns. Free exchange on sizing." Link it to the full text.
Say what happens with exchanges and faults
Keep these separate from change-of-mind returns. A faulty or damaged item is a different case, and the shopper wants to know you will deal with it without an argument. Tell them how to report it and what you need from them, such as a photo.
Keep the tone consistent with your brand
A relaxed store can write relaxed rules. A premium store can be formal. The mistake is a warm homepage and a cold policy, which feels like a trap.
Common gaps to check
- The policy exists but is not linked from the footer.
- The returns window on the product page differs from the one on the policy page.
- The refund timing is missing.
- There is no contact route for returns.
Any one of these can undo the reassurance you were trying to give. A store audit reads your policy pages and checks that the basics are present and consistent with what the product pages say.
Check your own store
Run the audit on your store
200+ checks in under two minutes. Free, no signup.